Tuesday, April 29, 2008

The Clan of the Cave Bear - Jean M. Auel

Rating: 2 1/2
Read for: TBR Challenge 2008

The Clan of the Cave Bear is the first in the Earth's Children series, which Auel began back in 1980 and is still writing today. Read for my TBR Challenge.

With a prehistoric setting when Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon man shared the earth, the titular "Clan" are a group of Neanderthal who are searching for a new home after theirs was destroyed by a terrible earthquake. On their journey, the medicine woman, Iza, discovers an orphaned Cro-Magnon girl and cares for her until the girl inadvertantly leads them to a perfectly situated cave. The leader of the Clan is persuaded to let Iza adopt the girl, Ayla, and slowly she is accepted by most of the Clan members.

The story follows Ayla as she is raised by Iza and Creb, the Clan's powerful holy man, as she struggles to assimilate into the Ways of the Clan. However, Ayla is not Clan, and is drawn to many things most of the Clan shy away from, such as open water, and often behaves most unlike a Clan woman, such as learning to hunt. Although seem as good luck by most of the Clan, Ayla makes an enemy of their future leader, Broud, and her transition from child to woman, and woman to medicine woman is fraught with angst and pain.

Although I have been looking forward to reading this series for some time, I was somewhat disheartened that within the first 3 or 4 chapters, I was very ready to give up. I was simply finding it boring and struggled to keep interested in the characters. Auel has done a staggering amount of research and her descriptions of the Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon people and their way of life is genuinely astounding, which combined with her creative imagination has led to some really interesting storytelling. However, the drawback was that Auel's descriptive prose was overly long and far too detailed for my enjoyment, often with several pages describing a simple activity. I did persevere with all 587 pages, and found that by the end I had quite enjoyed the experience, after a while (half the book!) becoming quite absorbed in this prehistoric world. The end is left quite open, as usual with such an extended series (five books and counting) and though I do wonder where Auel will take some of her characters, I do not feel particularly inclined to read further. Reviews of the follow ups are varied, and although her work is generally praised, the titles seem to get longer and longer and I truly think my patience would be tried!

So I'm going to call it a day. I'm glad I've finally read this book (I now know what the hype is about!) and will no longer be drawn to this section in bookshops! It has been quite refreshing reading outside the usual realms of fantasy that I find myself in, but I am a little disappointed that the book has not triggered any interest in prehistoric man or the Ice Age, as I had hoped.

The Clan of the Cave Bear most definitely lives up to its "magnificent epic" acclaim, but is a bit too epic for me!

Other blog reviews:
Michelle at In the Louvre
Jeane at Dog Ear Diary

7 comments:

Ana S. said...

I'm sorry to hear this one was disappointing...I think the idea is an interesting one and I'd probably have picked it up as well. I don't think I've ever read a book set in pre-history. There's a lot of potential there, but if the writer makes it boring, then there's no way around it.

I hope you enjoy whatever you pick up next a lot more!

Anonymous said...

Hmm is all I have to say really! I haven't read it and it's definitely not at the top of my list, or even the middle, but one day maybe...

valentina said...

I looooooved this book when I read it as a teenager, but I absolutely don't remember it to be overly-descriptive or boring. It was really absorbing for me and went on reading the next two. The second is good but the third wasn't great so I stopped reading them.
I've read them in Italian so I'm suspecting that the translators did some cuts with the descriptive parts, it happens very often with very long books, so maybe that's why I didn't find it boring at all!

I feel bad now because I've included in my list of favourite books for the tl;dr challenge:P

Melody said...

I've came across this book a few times at the bookstore, but just didn't pick it up. And after reading your review, I don't think I'll put this to my wishlist, at least not now...

mariel said...

Nymeth - well, my theory is, if I don't try it, I'll never know. And now I know! I'm already getting stuck into my next book and really enjoying it.

Rhinoa - this book's been around since 1980, so there is certainly no hurry! ;)

Valentina - I find that even people who share a lot of interests/favourite books in common with me often like things that I really don't enjoy! It would be rather boring if we all liked exactly the same thing. Or perhaps this was just wrong place, wrong time for me and this book. I'm glad I stuck with it.

Melody - The books that I tend to read are either ones that jump out at me, books of films that I want to see but need to read first, or recommendations from friends or from good reviews in the press. I don't think a book should ever be forced, so if it doesn't feel right, I say leave it!

The Bookworm said...

sorry you didn't like this one.
the plot sounds like it would be interesting, especially with the whole 'prehistoric' setting.

but I don't like it when the author overdescribes things, it tends to get boring.

http://thebookworm07.blogspot.com/

Julie said...

I loved this book as a teenager also. I still think about it a lot. All the subsequent books in the series are horrible, though.

I came via Weekly Geeks, by the way. I love your blog and I'm sorry I didn't find it before I posted my links. :)